The L'oreal one is slightly more dewy, but not very noticeable. The both have great coverage, but the Maybelline one has fuller coverage. However, I prefer the L'oreal one, because all of the Maybelline ones are too pink for me even if the shade is labeled as "warm undertones" (118, 120, 125, and 128 were all too pink for me!). NQBkkY.